BLACK SWANS OF THE STOCK MARKET: LESSONS FROM UNEXPECTED CRASHES

In a financial context, a “black swan” is an extremely rare, unexpected event that is hard to predict and has a huge impact on the market. As experts note, such an event is “extremely difficult or impossible to predict,” and its consequences can be very significant. In simple terms, it’s a turn of events no one expected that suddenly upends the market’s usual picture. When a “black swan” occurs, investors always find explanations afterward, but these events cannot be identified in advance. This article is about such crises.

At the end of the 1990s, amid the internet-technology boom, the “dot-com bubble” grew relentlessly. Shares of young, unprofitable internet companies skyrocketed — in 1999 the Nasdaq rose 86% and reached a record 5,048 points in March 2000. It seemed the rise would never end: deals like the AOL–Time Warner merger were worth hundreds of billions, and investors believed in a “new economy.”

But in March 2000 the bubble burst. Over the next two-plus years the Nasdaq plunged almost 77% — by October 2002 it had fallen to 1,139 points, and thousands of “hollow” companies vanished from the market. For many this was a complete surprise. No one expected such a crash: investors had grown used to believing the internet was changing the rules of the game and were too slow to notice that there were no fundamental grounds for the growth. As a result, billions of dollars “deflated” within months.

Lessons for investors: the dot-com bubble taught that behind frenzied demand there must be real business metrics. If a company doesn’t earn money, its “magical” growth can turn into the disappearance of invested funds. Investors should evaluate fundamentals — profit, revenue and industry prospects — instead of chasing hype. Simple diversification would have softened the blow: those who held not only “heated” tech stocks but also more conservative assets suffered less.

In 2007–2008 the housing market collapse and the resulting credit-financial tsunami became a “black swan.” Many low-income borrowers took subprime mortgages, and banks packaged them into complex securities. When housing prices began to fall, millions of borrowers could not make payments and banks suffered colossal losses. In September 2008 the large investment bank Lehman Brothers collapsed — and panic began.

What happened: indices fell by roughly half. By February 2009 the U.S. stock market had dropped almost 50% from pre-crisis highs. On September 29, 2008 the Dow Jones fell nearly 780 points in a single day — at the time a record decline. Globally, from January to October 2008 investors lost about $8 trillion — from $20 trillion to $12 trillion in total market capitalization. The economy went into a deep recession, unemployment spiked, and governments had to bail out banks and roll out stimulus packages.

Why it was unexpected: many considered the housing market “safe” and didn’t see a bubble. Even Fed Chair Alan Greenspan later admitted the crisis was so unpredictable that he “couldn’t imagine” it happening. Financial institutions failed to properly assess the risks of derivatives, and regulators missed the dangerous lax lending. For ordinary investors the warning signs were also not obvious: until late 2007 the market seemed stable and “anchor” assets were considered reliable.

Lessons for investors: this crisis showed that even supposedly safe “fundamental” assets can lose value during a systemic shock. Beyond diversification across asset classes (for example, holding not only stocks but also bonds, gold, currencies), it’s important to monitor the state of the economy: watch for credit bubbles and overvaluation of property. Never “buy at the top” and forget stop-loss rules. As investor Schwarzman says, good times don’t last forever, so build portfolios with a margin of safety.

In February–March 2020 the world faced the COVID-19 pandemic. The spread of the virus and the lockdowns announced worldwide instantly shocked markets.

What happened: from February 24 to 28, 2020 leading stock indices suddenly fell by 10% in six trading days — the fastest correction in trading history. Soon, by March 23, 2020 the S&P 500 had dropped 34% from its February peak. Companies suspended dividends, gold reserves rose, and oil futures even fell into negative territory. However, by summer 2020 the market had sharply recovered: thanks to massive support measures and positive news about effective treatments, investors quickly moved past the panic.

Why it was unexpected: the COVID-19 pandemic was hard to foresee — there had been no comparable global shutdowns of the world economy in modern history. Prior to the March crash most analysts forecast continued market growth: the U.S. economy was still expanding. The sudden appearance of the virus and the introduction of lockdowns completely disrupted those expectations.

Lessons for investors: the pandemic showed that an unforeseen external shock can instantly crush even a strong economy. It also reminded investors not to panic. Those who kept their composure and did not sell at the first sign of trouble were back in the market by mid-year during the subsequent rally in tech stocks. For private investors it’s important to have an untouchable liquidity cushion (an emergency “rainy day” fund) and to use averaging rules (for example, buying more shares during declines).

The year 2025 on the American market hardly resembled a classic “crash.” Largely thanks to the AI boom and easing monetary policy, indices rose again. For 2025 the S&P 500 gained about 16.4%, the Dow Jones 13.4%, and the Nasdaq 20.5%. Many “AI stocks” also recorded record growth: for example, NVIDIA’s market capitalization reportedly reached $5 trillion.

However, in spring 2025 there was a troubling shakeup. Donald Trump announced broad new tariffs on Chinese imports and investors panicked: exchanges fell for a short time. As The Guardian noted, the plan “spooked investors in the spring,” but markets then “reacted only slightly,” and fears “gave way to optimism” because of tech giants. Trump quickly softened his statements, and by year-end the U.S. market had fully recovered.

Unexpectedness vs. predictability: the idea of imposing large tariffs could have been anticipated given prior policy, but the scale and the market reaction were surprising. The growth of AI stocks was also seen by many as a bubble: rising valuations of NVIDIA and others raised concerns of overheating. Nevertheless, there was no truly catastrophic crash: the visible correction lasted only a couple of days before the market rebounded.

Lessons for investors: in spring 2025 we saw that even scary statements affect markets only briefly if the fundamentals are favorable. The main rule is not to give in to emotion. Investors who didn’t panic-sell and waited for clarification quickly regained profit. It’s important to keep a balanced portfolio: growth in the AI sector makes it an important part of a portfolio, but only as one component rather than the whole portfolio. Also remember that much of 2025’s high returns were driven by prior market accumulation — it was still profitable for many to keep investing.

Despite the optimism at the end of 2025, analysts warn of familiar but dangerous risks. Bloomberg notes that valuations of key assets are still elevated and inflation “has not yet been beaten.” Many stocks look expensive and credit spreads are very tight. It is also pointed out that debt has risen: the U.S. pushed public debt to nearly 100% of GDP (about $38 trillion), and without long-term fiscal measures a budget crisis could be “inevitable.”

Political and geopolitical factors can also become unexpected burdens. Morgan Stanley warns of rising risks “from populist measures to military interventions,” and Jerry Corry suggested that portfolios should be diversified and tilted toward “quality” assets to guard against risk. Overheating in AI investments is also a time bomb: for example, the Nasdaq has risen more than 110% since the appearance of ChatGPT, and many paper “stars” are extremely highly valued. External factors should not be forgotten either: trade conflicts, slowing economies and rising global debt could trigger shocks in autumn 2026.

History shows: black swans will appear again, and they never give advance warning. How should an ordinary investor act? The answer is simple — keep discipline and balance. Do not panic at sharp declines: many investors who sold “in fear” missed out when markets quickly bounced back (2020, 2025). In pursuit of profit, don’t forget diversification — invest not in a single stock or sector, but combine different asset types.

Many experts agree: focus on “quality” investments and keep part of capital in more stable assets (bonds, cash, gold). As Morgan Stanley recommends, given current risks “investors may focus on portfolio diversification and quality-oriented strategies to manage risks.” Accumulating a liquidity cushion and sensible allocation will help survive a shock without losing sleep.

And one more thing: “black swans” are not always bad. They can also bring unimaginable profits (as happened with Taleb, who made millions from the 2008 market collapse by using option strategies). The main thing is to treat events realistically, keep emotions under control, and use every crisis as an opportunity to rethink strategy.

Invest wisely and patiently — then even an unexpected “black swan” won’t be the end of the road, but another lesson on the way to success.

Open a free brokerage account with Unibank Invest and start investing. The Unibank Invest app provides access to the world’s largest stock exchanges, enabling you to purchase international investment instruments, such as stocks, bonds, and ETFs.

To open a brokerage account, fill out the online application or call +374 43 004 382.